Designated for publication Willett, J. (Wiener, Willett, Ho), Ho, J., dissenting; criminal, search and seizure Affirming grant of motion to suppress evidence, begrudgingly. The exclusionary rule has long provoked controversy, with critics deriding it as a blunt judicial tool that frees the guilty when police make mistakes. The oft-quoted Cardozo line—“the criminal is to go … More August 29, 2025, opinions
Designated for publication Jones, J. (Elrod, Jones, Stewart), Stewart, J., concurring in judgment only; insurance Reversing judgment in favor of insurer in claim brought by re-insurer, on basis that insurer’s delay in providing notice to re-insurer of claims was objectively unreasonable and material. The Fifth Circuit reversed a district court ruling and held that United … More August 14, 2025, opinions
Designated for publication Dennis, J. (Jones, Dennis, Willett); Willett, J., concurring; Jones, J., dissenting; qualified immunity, municipal liability Reversing summary judgment dismissal on qualified immunity grounds of excessive force claims arising from violent arrest of plaintiff, holding that the defendant officer “failed to show the absence of a genuine dispute of material fact as to … More August 29-30, 2024, opinions
Another quick-blurb catch-up post (the briefing and arguing has been non-stop since mid-July–Take the Fifth may need to take on some more staff!). Designated for publication Southwick, J. (Barksdale, Southwick, Graves), criminal, Sixth Amendment, sentencing Affirming conviction and sentence on fraud under the Paycheck Protection Program, upholding denial of motion to substitute counsel and district … More August 1-15, 2024, opinions
Designated for publication per curiam (Jones, Dennis, Douglas), immigration Denying Honduran citizen’s petition for review of BIA order denying motion to reopen removal proceedings for adjustment of status based on marriage to U.S. citizen. The Court held that the petitioner was never previously validly admitted to the U.S. as a nonimmigrant because, while he had … More March 4, 2024, opinions
Designated for publication Duncan, J. (Jones, Stewart, Duncan), personal jurisdiction, international arbitration, maritime law Reversing district court’s confirmation of international arbitration award of $200 million arising from explosion of chemical tanks aboard plaintiff’s chartered vessel, holding that the loading of the chemical tanks on the vessel in the Port of New Orleans was insufficient to … More January 29, 2024, opinions
Designated for publication per curiam (Richman, Jones, Smith, Barksdale, Elrod, Willett, Ho, Duncan, Engelhardt, Oldham, Wilson, JJ., voting for stay; Stewart, Southwick, Haynes, Graves, Higginson, Douglas, JJ., voting against stay); Oldham, J., concurring (joined by Jones, Smith, Barksdale, Elrod, Willett, Duncan, Engelhardt, Wilson, JJ.); Richman, C.J., concurring; Ho, J., concurring (joined by Elrod, J.); Higginson, … More December 7, 2023, opinions
Designated for publication per curiam (en banc Court), Voting Rights Act Granting en banc rehearing of November 10 panel opinion that affirmed the district court’s injunction against County’s redistricting plan that eliminated a majority-minority county commissioner district, but that had expressly requested an en banc poll on the basis of the panel’s disagreement with binding Circuit precedent … More November 28, 2023, opinions
Designated for publication Southwick, J. (King, Elrod, Southwick), Voting Rights Act Vacating district court’s preliminary injunction to enjoin Louisiana legislature’s 2022 congressional redistricting maps on the basis that the failure to create a second majority-Black district violated section 2 of the Voting Rights Act, and remanding for further proceedings to allow the legislature until January … More November 9-10, 2023, opinions
Designated for publication Jolly, J. (Jolly, Southwick, Oldham), Oil Pollution Act, CERCLA Affirming summary judgment dismissal of OPA claims arising from spill of mixture of oil and hazardous substances into the Houston shipping channel, holding that the mixed spill is not a spill of “oil” under OPA, but instead falls within the carve-out for CERCLA … More October 25-27, 2023, opinions
